The Elizabeth Street Garden in Manhattan’s Little Italy will be demolished since its lease ended on September 10. Started in 1991 by an antiques dealer, it has been a key green space in the area. In 2013, New York City proposed building a 123-unit affordable housing complex for seniors on this one-acre garden. Despite opposition from public figures like Robert De Niro and Martin Scorsese, the project will go ahead. Though other sites were suggested, city officials are sticking to the original plan. With the lease expired, it is now hard to stop the garden’s closure. Mayor Eric Adams wants to increase affordable housing in New York City because there are not enough homes. The city’s vacancy rate has dropped to 1.4%, the lowest since 1968. Adams’ “City of Yes” plan, started in 2022, hopes to build 500,000 new homes by 2032. This includes turning unused office buildings into homes and adding apartments above stores. Some people worry this might overcrowd neighborhoods or change their character, but others think it is needed to solve the housing problem. The Elizabeth Street Garden situation shows the ongoing conflict between building new homes and keeping green spaces in New York City.